Explaining success and failure in the commons: the configural nature of Ostrom’s institutional design principles

Publication Details

Related Case Studies

• Ain Sultan Irrigation System, Sidi Lahcen, Morocco
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Ain Sultan irrigation system is located northwest from the town of Sefrou in Morroco. It encompasses an unknown geographical area which is characterized by very little precipitation and a …
• Ait Sidi Musa Irrigation System, Sefrou, Morocco
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Ait Sidi Musa irrigation system is located northwest from the town of Sefrou in Morroco. It encompasses a geographical area of approximately 147 ha which is characterized by little …
• Ballynakill Harbour multi-use co-operative, Connemara District, Ireland
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  Ballynakill Harbour is located on the northwest part of Connemara, a region on the west coast of Ireland. Use of the harbor has moved from predominantly single-use, involving commercial and …
• Chilika Lake Traditional and Prawn Fishery (pre-1990s and 1990 to 1997), India
  Resource: Lake ecosystem
  Chilika Lake is located in Orissa, India, and extends from the city of Bhusandpur in the north to the city of Rambha-Mulad in the south. The lake follows the coastal …
• Common property regime of the Huaorani Indians (modern), Ecuador
  Resource: Rainforest ecosystem and associated watershed
  Contemporary Huaorani Indian society is scattered into approximately two dozen villages located in an area that encompasses the Napo, Orellana, and Pastaza provinces in the Ecuadorian Amazon region. The case …
• Common property regime of the Huaorani Indians, Ecuador
  Resource: Rainforest ecosystem and associated watershed
  Historically the Huaorani Indian society encompassed an area of 20,000 km2 in the Ecuadorian Amazonian region bordered on the north by the Napo River and the south by the Curaray …
• Communal irrigation management, Lari, Colca Valley, Peru
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This study focuses on water use in irrigation.  The case is characterized by well-defined boundaries: Once water enters an irrigation cluster it comes under the control of the landowners. There …
• Community coral reef fishery, Ahus village, Ahus Island, Papua New Guinea
  Resource: Marine coral reef ecosystem
  The Ahus village coral reef is located off of the west coast of Manus Island north of Karkar Island and the mainland of Papua New Guinea. Approximately 600 residents live …
• Community coral reef fishery, Muluk village, Karkar Island, Papua New Guinea
  Resource: Marine coral reef ecosystem
  The Muluk community coral reef fishery is located on the eastern side of Karkar Island off the northern shores of the Madang Province in Papua New Guinea. Karkar Island is …
• Community forest, Dhulikhelko Thulo Ban, Kabhrepalanchok district, Nepal (I)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This article examines the role played by local institutions in determining the conditions of two forests located in the Middle Hills of Nepal. Of the two forest systems (the forest, its …
• Community forest, Jyalachitti, Kabhrepalanchok district, Nepal (II)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This article examines the role played by local institutions in determining the conditions of two forests located in the Middle Hills of Nepal. Of the two forest systems (the forest, its …
• Fishing Networks Along Lake Titicaca in Peru and Bolivia
  Resource: Lake ecosystem
  The fishery of Lake Titicaca is located off the shores of Lake Titicaca which encompasses Peru and Bolivia. The original case spans a time period from approximately the mid 1960s …
• Gitksan commercial salmon fisheries along the Skeena river, British Columbia, Canada
  Resource: River ecosystem
  The Gitksan commercial salmon fisheries are located in west central British Columbia, Canada along a 200 kilometre length of the upper Skeena River in six reserve communities including: Kitwanga, Kispiox, …
• Haskovo's Irrigation System A, southern Bulgaria
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Haskovo region is located along the southern border of Bulgaria near both Turkey and Greece. The four study sites contained within the case study are deliberately kept anonymous but …
• Haskovo's Irrigation System B, southern Bulgaria
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Haskovo region is located along the southern border of Bulgaria near both Turkey and Greece. The four study sites contained within the case study are deliberately kept anonymous but …
• Haskovo's Irrigation System C, southern Bulgaria
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Haskovo region is located along the southern border of Bulgaria near both Turkey and Greece. The four study sites contained within the case study are deliberately kept anonymous but …
• Haskovo's Irrigation System D, southern Bulgaria
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Haskovo region is located along the southern border of Bulgaria near both Turkey and Greece. The four study sites contained within the case study are deliberately kept anonymous but …
• Huaynacotas Community Irrigation System in Peru
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Huaynacotas community is located in the province of La Union, Department of Arequipa, in the southern highlands of Peru.  The associated canal network spans elevations from 3,100 to 4,100 …
• La Campa Municipio Community Forests, Honduras
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The La Campa municipio community forests are located in the Department of Lempira, western Honduras.  The community forests encompass an unknown geographical area that is characterized by a mountainous landscape, …
• Land-cover and Forest in Nepal (I)
  Resource: Forest ecosystem and associated mountain topography
  Between 1978 and 1992 dramatic forest conversion occurred in two adjacent sub-basins of the Kair Khola watershed in the Chitwan District of Nepal. However, the form of conversion differed significantly. In …
• Land-cover and Forest in Nepal (II)
  Resource: Forest ecosystem and associated mountain topography
  Between 1978 and 1992 dramatic forest conversion occurred in two adjacent sub-basins of the Kair Khola watershed in the Chitwan District of Nepal. However, the form of conversion differed significantly. …
• Large N Comparative Studies of Ostrom's Design Principles
  Resource: Multiple
  There have been a number of studies that focus on testing whether and in what contexts Ostrom's institutional design principles may lead to successful governance of common-pool resources.  The study …
• Las Cebollas protective forest, Quezaltepeque municipality, western Guatemala
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  Las Cebollasforest community is located in the municipality of Quezaltepeque, in western Guatemala.  It encompasses a geographical area of 1850 ha of land much of it on slopes of about …
• Maritime Extractive Reserve (MER) and Traditional Beach Seining in Arraial do Cabo, Brazil
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The Arraial do Cabo Marine Extractive Reserve (MER) and fishing community is located on a cape that extends approximately 40 km into the ocean about 164 km east of Rio …
• NGO-facilitated community irrigation system in Kasungu district, Malawi
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The exact location of the Malawi irrigation system is undisclosed due to anonymity concerns.  However, it is generally located in the administrative district of Kasungu in central Malawi and encompasses …
• Newfoundland Inshore Cod Trap Fisheries, Canada
  Resource: Marine ecosystem
  The inshore cod trap fisheries discussed in this case are primarily located along the eastern and north shores of Newfoundland, Canada, encompassing an unknown geographical area.  The case study discusses …
• Nyamaropa Communal Area, Nyanga District, Zimbabwe
  Resource: Woodland ecosystem
  The Nyamaropa communal area encompasses a total of five villages located in the Nyanga District in Zimbabwe.  Beyond individual homestead plots and fields, the communities have access rights to an …
• Oyster communities, Florida, USA
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The Florida oyster fishing communities are located on the Florida “panhandle” with approximately 300 kilometers of coastline on the northern coast of the Gulf of Mexico. The case study states …
• Oyster communities, Gulf of Mexico, Alabama, USA
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The Alabama oyster fishing communities are located on the Gulf of Mexico with approximately 100 kilometers of coastline. The case study states that this is an open-access fishery but includes …
• Oyster communities, Gulf of Mexico, Louisiana, USA
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The Louisiana oyster fishing communities are located on the Gulf of Mexico with approximately 400 kilometers of coastline in a straight line from the border of Texas on the west …
• Oyster communities, Gulf of Mexico, Mississippi, USA
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The Mississippi oyster fishing communities are located on the Gulf of Mexico with approximately 100 kilometers of coastline. The case study states that this is an open-access fishery but includes …
• Rural coastal fishing community, south of Mombasa, Kenya
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The fishing community contained in this case study is located approximately 50 km south of the city of Mombasa on the coast of Kenya, outside of the Diani/Chale National Marine …
• Rural sokshing, Bhutan (I)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  Following the introduction of the Forest Act of 1969 and the Forest and Nature Conservation Act of 1995, the forests of Bhutan are owned and managed by the state, and …
• San Martin Ocotlán community forest management, Oaxaca, Mexico
  Resource: Forest ecosystem and associated watershed
  The San Martin Ocotlán forest community encompasses a total of six settlements located in the state of Oaxaca, Mexico, of which San Martin Ocotlán is the largest. The community has …
• Semi-urban sokshing, Bhutan (II)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  Following the introduction of the Forest Act of 1969 and the Forest and Nature Conservation Act of 1995, the forests of Bhutan are owned and managed by the state, and …
• Shellfish, Wadden Sea, The Netherlands
  Resource: Coastal marine ecosystem
  The Wadden Sea is a network of tidal channels, sandbars, mudflats, salt marshes and dune islands covering approximately 9000 km2 located at the northwest corner of the Netherlands along the …
• Stakenet Fishery Association at Negombo Lagoon, Sri Lanka
  Resource: Coastal lagoon ecosystem
  Negombo Lagoon (3,164 ha) is located on Sri Lanka's west coast -- about 30 km north of the capital Colombo. This study discusses a community-initiated common property regime in the …
• Taos valley acequias community-based irrigation system, Taos, New Mexico, USA
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  Key findings: The Taos valley acequias have survived for several hundred years as a community-based irrigation system due to a mix of social and biophysical features. These include: A low-cost …
• The Irrigation System of Campo Montiel, La Mancha region, Spain
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  Campo de Montiel Irrigation system is based on an aquifer of 2500 km2, but only that only 3% of it was used for agriculture. Campo de Montiel is located in …
• The Irrigation System of La Mancha Oriental, La Mancha Region, Albacete and Cuenca provinces, Spain
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Mancha Oriental Irrigation system is one aquifer of La Mancha Region, located in Albacete and Cuenca provinces in Spain. The case study involves an analysis of the evolution of the …
• The Irrigation System of Sol y Arena, Campo de Dalías, Almeria, Spain
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Sol y Arena Irrigation system is one of the six irrigation systems (the most irrigated one) of the agricultural area of Campo de Dalías, which is located in Almería, …
• The Irrigation System of Sol y Poniente, Campo de Dalías, Almeria, Spain
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Sol y Poniente Irrigation system is one of the six irrigation systems of the agricultural area of Campo de Dalías, which is located in Almería, Spain. The case study involves …
• Traditional irrigation practices of Ladakh (Alchi village), India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The village of Alchi is located on the banks of the Indus river in the Ladakh division of the Jammu and Kashmir districts, India.  It encompasses an unknown geographical area …
• Traditional irrigation practices of Ladakh (Sabu village), India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The village of Sabu (aka Saboo) is located several km from the town of Leh in the Ladakh division of the Jammu and Kashmir districts, India.  It encompasses an unknown …
• Traditional irrigation practices of Ladakh (villages of Phuktse, Shara, and Sharnos), India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The villages of Phuktse, Shara, and Sharnos are located in the Ladakh division of the Jammu and Kashmir districts, India.  The villages are successively downstream from each other, beginning with …
• Traditional irrigation practices of Ladakh (villages of Phyang and Phey), India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The villages of Phyang and Phey are located northwest and southwest from the town of Leh in the Ladakh division of the Jammu and Kashmir districts, India, and are upstream …
• Village 1 forest community, Almora district, India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The community forests discussed in this case study are called panchayat forests. They are managed by local institutions called van panchayats. The forests and van panchayats all lie in the …
• Village 2 forest community, Almora district, India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The community forests disccused in this case study are called panchayat forests. They are managed by local institutions called van panchayats. The forests and van panchayats all lie in the …
• Village 3 forest community, Almora district, India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The community forests discussed in this case study are called panchayat forests. They are managed by local institutions called van panchayats. The forests and van panchayats all lie in the …
• Village 4 community forest, Almora District, Uttarakhand, India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The community forests discussed in this case study are called panchayat forests. They are managed by local institutions called van panchayats. The forests and van panchayats all lie in the …
• Village 5 community forest, Almora district, Uttarakhand, India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The community forests discussed in this case study are called panchayat forests. They are managed by local institutions called van panchayats. The forests and van panchayats all lie in the …
• Village 6 community forest, Almora district, Uttarakhand, India
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The community forests discussed in this case study are called panchayat forests. They are managed by local institutions called van panchayats. The forests and van panchayats all lie in the …
• Water user association of the Fuente Palmera, Córdoba, Spain
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Fuente y Palmera Irrigation association involves 5 municipalities (Fuente Palmera, Hornachuelos, Écija, Posadas, y Guadalcázar) in the Guadalquivir Basin, in Spain.The resource unit is surface water (mainly from Guadalquivir …
• Water users association, Nishikanbara land improvement area, Niigata Prefecture, Japan
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  The Nishikanbara Land Improvement area is located nearly in the middle of the coastal region of Niigata Prefecture. It is an elliptic zone, 15 km from east to west, and …
• Watershed management, Ban Luang, Nan province, northern Thailand (III)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This paper examines four case studies of community-based watershed management with emphasis on their operational decision-making arrangements. Even though legally the watersheds are state property, 73% of the villagers consider them …
• Watershed management, Ban Pae, Chiang Mai province, northern Thailand (II)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This paper examines four case studies of community-based watershed management with emphasis on their operational decision-making arrangements. Even though legally the watersheds are state property, 73% of the villagers consider them …
• Watershed management, Silalaeng, Nan province, northern Thailand (I)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This paper examines four case studies of community-based watershed management with emphasis on their operational decision-making arrangements. Even though legally the watersheds are state property, 73% of the villagers consider them communal …
• Watershed management, Thung Kao Hang, Lamphun province, northern Thailand (IV)
  Resource: Watershed and associated topography
  This paper examines four case studies of community-based watershed management with emphasis on their operational decision-making arrangements. Even though legally the watersheds are state property, 73% of the villagers consider …
• Yanesha Forest Cooperative, Palcazú valley, central Peru
  Resource: Forest ecosystem and associated watershed
  The Yanesha forest community is located in the Palcazú valley of central Peru. The case study involves a snapshot in time during which the Yanesha Forestry Cooperative (COFYAL) operated in …
• Yuracare forest community, Department of Cochabamba, northern Bolivia
  Resource: Forest ecosystem and associated watershed
  The Yuracare forest community is located in the department of Cochabamba, in northern Bolivia.  It encompasses a geographical area of 250,000 ha in the Rio Charape watershed. The case study …